| SOCIAL ISSUES |Yenidüzen

THE BALANCE OF THE SCALE IS OFF, AGAIN

This post is also available in: ΕΛΛΗΝΙΚΑ (GREEK) TÜRKÇE (TURKISH)

Last night, police checks were carried out in many areas in the north of Cyprus under the name of a ‘peace operation’.

Traffic offence checks, body searches, identity checks and general public order checks are, of course, part of the state’s duties in the context of public safety. However, the images that emerged while this duty was being carried out resemble scenes from an action film rather than a security practice.

People lined up against walls for body searches, their faces exposed, their identities made visible in the media, and the operation turned into a spectacle; this poses serious problems in terms of the rule of law, and human rights and freedoms.

At this point, a reminder is much needed:

• Presumption of innocence: A person cannot be declared guilty in the absence a court decision.

• Right to privacy: The fact that a body search is being carried out does not legitimise the exposure of the person.

• Principle of proportionality: The use of public authority must be appropriate, necessary and proportionate to the aim.

• Personal safety and dignity: These are protected by the Constitution’s most fundamental framework.

Rising crime rates are causing considerable concern within the society, for all the right reasons. People do not feel safe; no one accepts the transformation of the country into ‘free-for-all’, that gunmen should be able to enter easily, or that deaths and injuries on the roads should continue. However, combating crime does not give free rein to violate fundamental rights.

Using excessive force to alleviate social unease, disseminating images that constitute violation of rights, and disregarding people’s privacy are incompatible with the rule of law; they do not enhance security but, on the contrary, undermine trust.

Security policies only provide real security when they take their strength from rights and freedoms, do not pave way to arbitrariness, and are transparent and accountable.

Even in the steps you take, which you claim are beneficial for the country, you are unable to maintain a fair balance.

Maintaining public order is essential, yes; but this order should not be achieved through ‘tyranny’.

We desire both a secure society and a public order where our fundamental rights are not arbitrarily violated. We must remind ourselves that these are not alternatives to each other, but rather complementary to each other.

This article was originally published on 23.12.2025

Source: THE BALANCE OF THE SCALE IS OFF, AGAIN

image_printPrint
Share:
ASLI MURAT | YENİDÜZEN
I met the world on the 25th day of September in 1985. I do not know whether this is because I was born in autumn or not, but I have a melancholic nature. Melancholic but not sad. One should not be sad. Otherwise one can lose one’s belief in life. I grew up in a left-wing family environment that cared about equality and justice. Foundations of my tough and feminist stance were laid then. I studied Law in Istanbul University and became a lawyer in 2008. Then of course my soul was overwhelmed, I was unable to contain myself and I continued my studies in Istanbul Bilgi University Human Rights Law postgraduate program. After which, once again, I returned to the cage. I have been working as a lawyer, doing research in civil society, dealing in politics and writing since 2011, while dreaming of peace.

You may also like

Comments are closed.